Cosmetic claims in the EU and Great Britain — NorrChemica Analysis Notes, Cosmetics Series, Part 7. Navy card with nine claims on labels, each with the proof it needs; free from parabens is crossed out as not accepted.

Cosmetic claims in the EU and Great Britain: natural, vegan, cruelty-free, free from and eco, and the proof each one needs

Analysis Notes · Cosmetics Series · Part 7

Cosmetic claims in the EU and Great Britain: natural, vegan, cruelty-free, free from and eco, and the proof each one needs

The six criteria used to judge every claim in both markets, what inspectors have found, the words that make a cosmetic a medicine, and the EU rules on environmental claims that have applied since 27 September 2026.

MARKETS EU · GREAT BRITAINRULES AS AT 17 NOV 2026

A claim is anything that describes what a cosmetic is or does, on the label, on a marketplace listing, on a website or in a social media post. The cosmetics law of the EU and Great Britain (GB) has no list of allowed or banned claims, except one rule on animal testing. Each claim is judged on its own wording and on the proof that the company holds.1,2

1. How a claim is judged

Article 20 of the EU Cosmetics Regulation, which GB kept after Brexit, states that the labelling, sale and advertising of a cosmetic must not suggest characteristics or functions that the product does not have. The rule applies to text, names, trade marks, pictures and other signs.1 A picture of a leaf, for example, can suggest that a product is natural.

The company named on the label is called the Responsible Person. It must make sure that every claim meets the six common criteria of Regulation (EU) No 655/2013.2 GB also kept this regulation, with minor changes to its wording, so the criteria are the same in both markets.

The six criteria are:2

  • Legal compliance: a claim must not present a legal requirement as a special benefit, or state that an authority has approved the product.
  • Truthfulness: the claim must be true of the finished product. For example, a product labelled "silicone-free" must not contain silicone.
  • Evidential support: every claim, stated or implied, needs adequate proof that can be checked, at the level that the claim requires.
  • Honesty: a claim must not state more than the proof shows, or present a feature as unique when similar products also have it.
  • Fairness: a claim must not unfairly criticise competitors or ingredients that are used legally.
  • Informed decision-making: a claim must be clear to the average buyer and help the buyer choose.

Almost every claim needs proof. The only exceptions are obvious exaggerations that no buyer would take literally, such as a cream "fit for a queen", and abstract statements, such as "a moment of pure luxury".2

The proof must be in the product information file (Article 11). The Responsible Person must hold this file for each product, show it to the authorities when asked, and keep it for ten years after the last batch is placed on the market.1,3

Authorities also use the Technical Document on Cosmetic Claims, which gives examples of claims that are accepted and claims that are not. It was agreed in 2017 by a working group of the European Commission and the Member States. It is not legally binding, but several EU authorities said they would apply it, and its annexes on "free from" and "hypoallergenic" claims have applied since 1 July 2019.4,5

The GB government guidance does not mention the Technical Document, but the CTPA, the UK trade association for cosmetics, recommends that companies follow it.3,5

The six common criteria for cosmetic claims, each with an example from the EU Technical Document on Cosmetic Claims: 1 legal compliance, free from corticosteroids, not accepted; 2 truthfulness, free from formaldehyde with diazolidinyl urea, not accepted; 3 evidential support, an in vitro result presented as an effect on skin, not accepted; 4 honesty, free from allergenic substances, not accepted; 5 fairness, free from parabens, not accepted; 6 informed decision-making, free from animal-derived ingredients on a vegan product, accepted.

Figure 1. The six common criteria of Regulation (EU) No 655/2013.

2. What inspectors have found

The EU survey

The Cosmetics Regulation required the European Commission to report on the use of claims. Its report of 2016 gives the only EU-wide figures that we found. In 2014 and 2015, authorities in 21 Member States checked 38,995 claims, and 3,730 of them (10%) did not meet the common criteria.6

Figure 2 shows the types of failed claim. The most common type, found in 16 of the 21 Member States, was an effect claimed without enough proof, for example a study that could not be reproduced, or the effect of an ingredient claimed for a product that contains too little of it.6

In some Member States, up to 70% of the failed claims were online, 17% were on the product itself and 13% were in brochures.6

Horizontal bar chart of the types of non-compliant cosmetic claims found by 21 EU Member States in 2014 and 2015: effect claimed without enough proof, 16 Member States; medicinal or therapeutic effect, 10; free from a legal ingredient, 10; hypoallergenic without evidence, 7; ingredient claimed but absent, 5; not tested on animals without evidence for every ingredient, 4. A second bar shows where the non-compliant claims were in some Member States: online up to 70 percent, on the product 17 percent, in brochures 13 percent.

Figure 2. Some Member States also found claims that a product was free from a banned ingredient or met quality standards; the report does not say how many.

France

France's consumer protection authority, the DGCCRF, publishes the most detailed recent results that we found. In 2021 it checked free-from claims at 336 establishments and found at least one problem at 40% of them. It also checked claims that a product contains an ingredient, such as "with argan oil", at 389 establishments, and found problems at 33% (Figure 3).7

It found these problems at small companies and at large international ones. Sections 5 and 6 give its examples.7

French checks in 2021. Free-from claims: 336 establishments, 40 percent with at least one problem; follow-up 83 warnings, 51 injunctions, 1 official report. With claims: 389 establishments, 33 percent with at least one problem; follow-up 68 warnings, 58 injunctions, 4 official reports.

Figure 3. A warning asks the company to comply, an injunction orders it to comply, and an official report (procès-verbal) records an offence.

Great Britain

We found no similar survey for GB. The GB examples in this article come from the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA), which applies the UK advertising code, the CAP Code, to adverts, including brands' own websites and social media posts.8,9

Products withdrawn for safety reasons are a separate subject, covered in our article on cosmetics recalls in the EU.

3. "Natural" and "organic"

Neither word is defined in the cosmetics law of the EU or GB.10 Their meaning comes from voluntary standards, certification schemes and the decisions of regulators.

Natural

ISO 16128 is a voluntary standard in two parts. Part 1 defines types of ingredient: for example, a "derived natural" ingredient is more than 50% natural in origin, measured by molecular weight or by renewable carbon content. Part 2 gives methods to calculate the natural and organic content of ingredients and finished products.11

Part 2 allows the natural content of a product to be calculated with or without the water in the formula. Water counts as natural, so a product that is mostly water can show a high natural content. The standard does not cover claims or labelling.11

In France, the DGCCRF's position is that a cosmetic may be called "natural" only if at least 95% of its ingredients are natural. Below 95%, it recommends stating which ingredients are natural and their percentages.12

In GB, two ASA rulings set limits. A ruling of 2003 found that a product with synthetic ingredients, such as a preservative, should not be called "100% natural". A ruling of 2013 found it misleading to claim that a product had no side effects because its ingredients were natural.8

In the EU, a brand name or product name with "natural" may also be covered by the new rules on environmental claims (section 10).13 The CTPA advises against vague terms such as "clean beauty" and recommends naming the natural or organic ingredients instead.10

Organic

Certification schemes set their own thresholds. The COSMOS standard was developed by BDIH (Germany), Cosmebio and Ecocert (France), ICEA (Italy) and the Soil Association (UK). Its version 4.2 (September 2025) sets these conditions for COSMOS ORGANIC:14

  • at least 95% of the plant, animal and microbial ingredients that have only been processed physically, for example chopped or blended, must be organic;
  • at least 20% of the whole product must be organic, or 10% for rinse-off products, water-based products that are not emulsions, and products with at least 80% minerals;
  • no more than 2% of the product may come from parts of molecules made from petroleum;
  • the label must show the COSMOS signature, the name of the certification body and the organic percentage, calculated on the whole product, without water and minerals (or without water and salt), or both ways;
  • the product must not be called "organic", for example "organic shampoo", unless at least 95% of the whole product is organic.

Water and minerals cannot be organic, so the two percentages can be very different for the same product (Figure 4). A product certified as COSMOS NATURAL has no minimum organic content.14

Example cream: 60 percent water, 5 percent minerals, 20 percent organic ingredients, 15 percent other ingredients. On the whole product the organic content is 20 divided by 100, 20 percent, label wording 20% organic of total; this is the basis for the 20 percent minimum of COSMOS ORGANIC. Without water and minerals it is 20 divided by 35, 57.14 percent, label wording 57% organic of total, minus water and minerals; rounding up is forbidden. The product may not be called organic cream, because a product name with organic needs at least 95 percent organic on the whole product.

Figure 4. A certified product must also meet the other conditions of the COSMOS standard.

In GB there is no national standard for organic cosmetics, so the ASA expects an "organic" claim to name the standard that the product meets. A whole range should not be called organic if only part of it is certified. In 2012 the ASA judged a product name with the word "Organics" misleading, because the product contained only 5% organic ingredients.8

Proof to keep. For "organic": the certificate, and the organic percentage from the certification body on each basis that the label shows. For "natural" or a natural-origin percentage: the origin of every ingredient and the method of calculation, for example ISO 16128, including whether water was counted.

4. "Vegan" and "cruelty-free"

Vegan

No law defines "vegan" for cosmetics. The EU Technical Document accepts "free from animal-derived ingredients" on a vegan product, because this information helps the buyer choose.4

The Vegan Society's trademark scheme registers individual products, not whole companies. A registered product must contain no animal ingredients, by-products or derivatives. Neither the product nor its ingredients may be tested on animals by the company, on its behalf or by companies under its control.15 In 2023 the Society had registered 30,000 vegan cosmetic products.16

Many buyers cannot check a vegan claim themselves. In a survey for the Vegan Society in July 2023, 43.1% of 1,000 UK adults were not confident that they could recognise animal-derived ingredients in beauty products, and 9.7% never checked the ingredients (Figure 5).16

Survey of 1,000 UK adults, July 2023, on confidence in recognising animal-derived ingredients in beauty products: very confident 11.6 percent, somewhat confident 35.6 percent, not very confident 32.6 percent, not at all confident 10.5 percent, never check ingredients 9.7 percent. Confident in total 47.2 percent; not confident in total 43.1 percent.

Figure 5. The Vegan Society reports similar results in its survey of 2021.

According to the Vegan Society, the most common animal-derived ingredients in cosmetics include:16

  • lanolin, from sheep;
  • beeswax (cera alba) and propolis, from bees;
  • carmine, from cochineal insects, and shellac, from lac insects;
  • guanine, from fish scales, and squalene, from shark liver;
  • collagen, from cows, and keratin, from animal hair and horns;
  • glycerine and retinol.

Glycerine is also made from vegetable oils, and the Vegan Society advises buyers to look for vegetable glycerine.16 The molecule and its name in the ingredient list are the same whatever the source, so only the supplier can confirm where it came from.

The European Commission's questions and answers on the new EU rules state that "vegan" can be an environmental claim or a sustainability label when it is presented as better for the planet.13

Cruelty-free and not tested on animals

In the EU and GB, a cosmetic may not be placed on the market if the final product or any of its ingredients was tested on animals to meet the requirements of the Cosmetics Regulation, and such tests are banned in both markets (Article 18).1 So every cosmetic on sale in either market meets this condition, whether its label says so or not.10

The CTPA considers that a "not tested on animals" claim or logo could therefore break the first criterion, legal compliance.10 In 2019 the DGCCRF asked manufacturers and importers to stop using the claim and related logos, which it considers misleading.17

If a brand still makes the claim, Article 20(3) sets the condition. Neither the manufacturer nor its suppliers may have carried out or commissioned animal tests on the finished product, its prototype or any of its ingredients. The product also may not contain ingredients that others tested on animals to develop new cosmetic products.1

Meeting this condition requires the testing history of every ingredient. Many cosmetic ingredients are also used in other industries whose laws still require animal tests, and the CTPA states that most, if not all, cosmetics contain one or more ingredients tested on animals by someone, at some time, for some purpose.18

In the EU survey, four Member States found "not tested on animals" claims and rabbit logos without evidence for all the ingredients.6 The product information file must also hold data on any animal testing by the manufacturer, its agents or its suppliers, including tests required by countries outside the EU and GB.1

Under the new EU rules, animal welfare is a social characteristic, so a brand's own "cruelty-free" badge may be a sustainability label. Such labels must now be based on a certification scheme (section 10).13 This is our reading: the Commission's questions and answers do not mention "cruelty-free".

Proof to keep. For "vegan": a statement from the supplier of every ingredient on its source, and the registration certificate if you use a scheme's logo. For "not tested on animals": statements on animal testing from the supplier of every ingredient, and the animal testing data that Article 11 requires in the file.

5. "Free from"

In the EU survey, about one product in five had a free-from claim, often "paraben free", and ten Member States found free-from claims that broke the fairness criterion.6

The EU Technical Document applies the six criteria to free-from claims. It does not accept these examples:4

  • "free from parabens", "free from phenoxyethanol" and "free from triclosan", because they unfairly criticise substances that are allowed (fairness);
  • "free from corticosteroids", because corticosteroids are already banned in cosmetics (legal compliance);
  • "free from formaldehyde", when the product contains an ingredient that releases formaldehyde, such as diazolidinyl urea (truthfulness);
  • "free from preservatives", when another ingredient, such as alcohol, protects the product, unless evidence shows that it does not (truthfulness);
  • "free from perfume", when an ingredient is used to give the product a scent (truthfulness);
  • "free from allergenic substances", because the risk of an allergic reaction can never be excluded (honesty).

It accepts "free from alcohol" on a family mouthwash and "free from acetone" on a nail polish, if the other criteria are met.4 A free-from claim is acceptable when the information helps the buyer choose and is true for every raw material, but not when it suggests that a legal ingredient is unsafe.

What French inspectors found

In 2021 the DGCCRF found free-from claims that the rules do not accept, such as "free from parabens", "free from phthalates", "free from endocrine disruptors", "zero controversial substances" and "clean formulation". It also ordered companies to correct these cases:7

  • ethanol in a product labelled "free from ethanol";
  • substances with an odour in products labelled "free from perfume";
  • "free from allergens*", with the asterisk explaining "in the fragrance composition";
  • "free from major allergens";
  • "safe composition".

Great Britain

The ASA has upheld complaints against free-from claims in recent years:

  • in 2023, against a deodorant advertised as aluminium-free, with claims that it was less irritating, less harmful and better performing than deodorants with aluminium, and the caption "No aluminiums or other harsh chemicals";9,19
  • in 2025, against a hair dye advertised as "PPD-free" that contained toluene-2,5-diamine sulfate, a chemical of the same family (the phenylenediamines), after a complaint by the CTPA.20

In 2012 an ASA ruling on hair dyes found "no formaldehyde" and "no nickel" misleading, because they suggested that competing products often contained these substances, which was not true.9

A "chemical-free" claim cannot be true, because every ingredient, including water, is a chemical substance. The CTPA states that free-from claims should not suggest that a product is safer, and that they can lead people with allergies to skip the ingredient list.10

Proof to keep. The full formula, and supplier documents showing that the substance is absent from every raw material, including blends and fragrance oils. For "preservative-free": evidence that no other ingredient protects the product. Our article on soap, balms, oils and other low-risk products explains when a product needs no preservative and no challenge test.

6. "With" claims: an ingredient named on the pack

Naming an ingredient, as in "with argan oil" or "20% laurel oil", is also a claim. In both markets, the common criteria set two conditions:2

  • the ingredient itself must be in the formula; a perfume with its scent is not enough (truthfulness);
  • if the product is said to have a property of the ingredient, the product must really have it, and the claim needs evidence, for example that the ingredient is present at an effective concentration (truthfulness and evidential support).

The EU Technical Document gives two examples. A claim about honey needs honey in the product, and a moisturising claim based on aloe vera is not accepted if the product does not moisturise.4

What French inspectors found

In 2021 the DGCCRF found ingredients named on the pack that were present only as a scent, or at a level far below the claim (Figure 6):7

  • an Aleppo soap that claimed 20% laurel berry oil contained 3.58%;
  • a product sold as "lemon verbena" contained 0.0005% verbena and 0.4% verbena perfume;
  • argan oil at 0.01% could not support claims that the product nourished and moisturised;
  • an active ingredient was used at 1% to support a firming claim, although its supplier recommended 5 to 10% for that effect.
Ingredients named in claims and the amounts found by the DGCCRF in 2021, on a logarithmic scale. Aleppo soap claiming 20 percent laurel berry oil: 3.58 percent found. Lemon verbena product: 0.0005 percent verbena and 0.4 percent verbena perfume. Firming claim: active ingredient at 1 percent, while the supplier recommends 5 to 10 percent. Argan oil with nourishing and moisturising claims: 0.01 percent. Royal jelly: 0.01 percent.

Figure 6. The product with royal jelly also contained other moisturising ingredients.

At six or more companies, the label did not show that the aloe vera was made from powder and water, and a court fined one of these companies €50,000 and its president €5,000. A large company that highlighted ingredients present at 0.01%, with 30 times as much perfume, accepted a settlement fine of €200,000.7

The DGCCRF adds that the ingredient must be present at more than a symbolic level. An effect claimed for the product must be shown by tests on the finished product, not by the properties of each ingredient, and if other ingredients have a similar effect, the tests must show that it comes from the ingredient named.7

In our reading, the same conditions apply to products sold in GB, because the common criteria are the same.

Proof to keep. The formula with the percentage of each ingredient named in a claim, and the supplier's specification, which shows whether an extract is diluted or made from powder. For an effect: the concentration at which the effect has been shown, and a test on the finished product.

7. "Hypoallergenic", "dermatologically tested", "clinically proven" and percentages

Hypoallergenic

The EU Technical Document allows "hypoallergenic" only on a product designed to minimise the risk of allergy. Known allergens should be avoided completely, including substances classified as skin sensitisers of category 1A or 1B. The Responsible Person should hold scientifically robust and statistically reliable data, such as records of reactions reported after sale, and keep the data up to date.4

The claim must not suggest that there is no risk at all, and the CTPA gives the same advice in the UK.4,10 In the EU survey, seven Member States found hypoallergenic claims without evidence, including on hair dyes that contained known allergens such as resorcinol and p-phenylenediamine.6

A study of 174 best-selling moisturisers in the US shows that the word on a label does not mean that the product is free of common contact allergens. Of the 18 products labelled "hypoallergenic", 15 contained at least one substance from a standard patch-test series used to diagnose contact allergy. Of the 40 products labelled "fragrance free", 18 contained a fragrance, an ingredient that cross-reacts with fragrance, or a plant ingredient (Figure 7).21

The data come from the US market in 2016, where the EU and GB rules do not apply.

Best-selling moisturisers in the US, 2016. Labelled hypoallergenic, 18 products: 83 percent, 15 of 18, contained at least one allergen from the NACDG patch-test series. Labelled dermatologist recommended, 40 products: 95 percent. Labelled fragrance free, 40 products: 45 percent, 18 of 40, contained a fragrance, an ingredient that cross-reacts with fragrance, or a plant ingredient. All 174 products: 88 percent, 153 of 174, contained at least one NACDG allergen.

Figure 7. The NACDG series is a standard list of substances used in patch tests to diagnose contact allergy. For "dermatologist recommended" the study gives only a percentage.

Tested and proven

The Technical Document defines two common claims:4

  • "Dermatologically tested": tested under the supervision of a dermatologist. A study in which consumers report how their own skin feels is not enough.
  • "Clinically tested": tested on people under the supervision of a medically or scientifically qualified professional, or according to a clinical protocol or in a clinical setting.

In GB, the CAP guidance states that claims about the effects of beauty products need tests on people, and that laboratory (in vitro) tests have often been found inadequate. A measurable effect, such as fewer dark spots, cannot be supported by a consumer survey; it should be observed in a clinical setting.8

In 2026 the ASA ruled against a poster for a serum said to be clinically proven to make users look up to five years younger and, in a separate ruling, against a skincare listing on a brand's own website that exaggerated the effects on ageing skin.9

Percentages from consumer tests

A claim such as "90% said their skin felt softer" needs a consumer test that follows the Technical Document's best practice:4

  • a sample that represents the target population;
  • a validated protocol;
  • balanced questions that do not lead the answer;
  • a claim that matches the result of the question;
  • suitable statistics and a signed report.

The document sets no minimum number of participants.4

The CAP guidance accepts some wording without evidence: references to temporary effects, to "the appearance of lines and wrinkles", and to nourishing or plumping the skin with moisture.8

The EU survey also found sun protection claims based on an ingredient at too low a concentration, and judged them dishonest.6 Sun protection has its own test methods, which this article does not cover.

Proof to keep. For "hypoallergenic": the review of the formula for known allergens, and the data on reactions after sale. For "tested", "proven" or a percentage: the study report, signed by the person responsible for the study, with the protocol, the participants, the results and the statistics.

8. Words that make a cosmetic a medicine or a biocide

A cosmetic is used only or mainly to clean, perfume or protect the body, to keep it in good condition, to change its appearance or to correct body odours.1 The MHRA, the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency in GB, adds that a cosmetic may have a secondary purpose of prevention, but not of treatment.22

In both markets, a product is a medicine if it is presented as treating or preventing disease, or if it is used to restore, correct or modify a body function by a pharmacological, immunological or metabolic action.22,23 In GB, "disease" includes "any injury, ailment or adverse condition, whether of body or mind".22

A product that meets the definition of a cosmetic and the definition of a medicine is classed as a medicine.23,24 In GB, selling or advertising a medicine without an authorisation from the MHRA is an offence.24,25

The MHRA's guidance and the CTPA guidance that follows it give these examples for skin products in GB:22,24

  • products to treat or prevent eczema, psoriasis or dermatitis are medicines, and "For eczema-prone skin" is a medicinal claim, because it is addressed to people who have the condition;
  • the only accepted wording is "Also suitable (or safe) for people who may be prone to eczema" (or to psoriasis, dermatitis, rosacea, acne or spots). It must be proved, must not be too prominent or distract from the cosmetic use, and may suggest only that the product will not make the condition worse;
  • products to treat, prevent or fight spots and acne are medicines, but a product that only covers them may be a cosmetic;
  • a claim to protect against nappy rash is not acceptable if it means preventing the condition;
  • "healing" is a claim to treat.

In 2025 the MHRA told the ASA that claims to treat "acne-related redness" are, in general, medicinal. The ASA also upheld a complaint against medicinal claims for an unlicensed cream on a beauty retailer's own website.9 A testimonial on the brand's website that describes a medicinal effect also counts as a medicinal claim for the product.22

Germ-killing claims

In GB, general claims to kill germs are acceptable for soaps, hand washes and hand gels. A claim to kill a named pathogen, such as MRSA, E. coli or the virus that causes Covid-19, makes a hand product a medicine, and so can a picture of a specific virus.25

A product intended to disinfect hands is a biocide. In GB, biocides are regulated by the Health and Safety Executive under the GB Biocidal Products Regulation.22,25

In the EU survey, ten Member States found claims of medicinal effects on cosmetics, for example on blood circulation, muscles, joints and inflammation, and most Member States considered these the most dangerous kind of misleading claim.6 In its 2019 checks of natural and organic cosmetics, the DGCCRF found claims such as "healing".12

Two products, each described in three ways. A balm: moisturises dry skin is a cosmetic claim; also suitable for people who may be prone to eczema is accepted only under the MHRA conditions; for eczema-prone skin or soothes eczema is a medicinal claim. A hand product: cleanses hands is a cosmetic claim; kills germs is accepted for a soap or hand wash, while a hand disinfectant is a biocide; kills MRSA is a medicinal claim.

Figure 8. Claims for a balm and a hand product in GB, from cosmetic to medicinal.

9. Words that change who the product is for

A claim can also change what the safety report must cover. The report must consider the normal and reasonably foreseeable use of the product, based on its labelling, and the people the product is meant for or who may be exposed to it.1

The Cosmetics Regulation requires a specific assessment for two groups of products: products for children under three, and products only for external intimate hygiene.1 So "for babies", "nappy balm" or "intimate wash" on a label, a listing or a website changes the assessment that the product needs.

Some ingredient rules also depend on age. Salicylic acid, for example, is allowed as a preservative up to 0.5% (as the acid), but not in products for children under three, except in shampoos. A product that contains it and might be used on young children must be labelled "Not to be used for children under 3 years of age".26 The same rule applies in the EU and GB.

The part of the body also matters: some colourants may not be used in products applied near the eyes. Our article on cosmetic colourants lists where each colourant may be used.

Claims that contradict the safety report

Every claim about who can use the product, and how, must match the safety report. When the DGCCRF checked 147 cosmetics businesses new to the sector, 90% of them very small, it found claims that did not (results published in February 2026):27

  • a label said that the product was suitable for the whole family, except infants and pregnant or breastfeeding women, but the safety assessor had written "adult use only", "do not apply to damaged or irritated skin" and "apply once a day";
  • a company that advertised on Instagram and TikTok described its product as suitable for sensitive skin, although the assessor had noted that no test supported this.

10. Environmental claims and badges

The EU since 27 September 2026

Directive (EU) 2024/825 added environmental claims to the EU list of commercial practices that are always unfair. Member States had to apply the new rules from 27 September 2026, including to products already on sale.13,28

These practices are now banned in the EU:28

  • a generic environmental claim, such as "eco-friendly", "green" or "biodegradable", unless the product has the EU Ecolabel, an officially recognised type I ecolabel (EN ISO 14024), or top environmental performance under other EU law that is relevant to the claim;
  • an environmental claim about the whole product when it concerns only one part of it;
  • a claim, based on carbon offsetting, that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive effect on greenhouse gas emissions;
  • presenting a legal requirement for all products of the category as a feature of the trader's own product;
  • a sustainability label that is not based on a certification scheme or set up by a public authority.

A claim is not generic if its details are given clearly and prominently on the same medium. The Commission's example of a specific claim is "100% of the energy used to produce this packaging comes from renewable sources", which must still be true and supported by evidence.13

A sustainability label is any voluntary trust mark or quality mark that promotes a product for its environmental or social characteristics. A certification scheme needs monitoring by an independent third party, a legal entity separate from the owner of the scheme.13,28

The Commission adds that buyers may see leaves or water drops combined with a logo or a sustainability statement as a trust mark. In our reading, a badge that a brand designs for itself may therefore be banned.13

For products already on sale, the Commission mentions stickers, or information where the product is sold, as practical ways to correct the packs.13

The Commission plans to withdraw its separate proposal for a Green Claims Directive, which would have required independent checks of claims before use, so the 2024 directive remains the EU rule.29

Two practices banned in the EU since 27 September 2026 and the alternatives. Words: the generic claim eco-friendly is banned unless the product has the EU Ecolabel or an official type I ecolabel; a specific claim such as 100 percent of the energy used to produce this packaging comes from renewable sources is allowed if true and proven. Badges: a badge the brand designed itself, which buyers may see as a trust mark, is banned unless based on a certification scheme; a label of a certification scheme with independent monitoring, or one set up by a public authority, is allowed.

Figure 9. Words and badges under the new EU rules.

Not yet in every national law

The directive applies through the law of each Member State. Member States had to adopt their laws by 27 March 2026, but on 5 October 2026 only 19 of the 27 had their measures in force (Figure 10). In May 2026 the Commission opened legal action (infringement proceedings) against 20 Member States, because they had not notified it of complete national laws.30

National laws also differ. A few countries apply the rules earlier or later than 27 September 2026, and some exempt goods already produced or on sale, which the directive does not provide for.30 A seller in several EU countries therefore needs to check the law of each country where it sells.

Directive (EU) 2024/825 in national law as at 5 October 2026, one square per Member State: 19 with measures in force, 1 with legislation passed and awaiting signature, 5 with draft laws or bills in progress, 2 with no measure put forward. In May 2026 the Commission opened infringement proceedings against 20 Member States.

Figure 10. Status of national laws.

Great Britain

GB has no equivalent list of banned environmental claims. Environmental claims in adverts, including websites and social media, must meet section 11 of the CAP Code:31

  • the basis of the claim and the meaning of its terms must be clear;
  • absolute claims need a high level of evidence;
  • claims must be based on the full life cycle of the product, unless the advert states otherwise;
  • an advert must not highlight the absence of an ingredient that competing products do not usually contain, or a benefit that comes from a legal obligation that competitors also meet.

Qualitative research by the ASA in 2023 found that people generally accepted green claims in adverts without question. They understood "recycled", but they were confused by "compostable" and least sure about "biodegradable". When told that "biodegradable" could refer to an unlimited time, and that some products release toxins as they break down, they were angry and frustrated.32

In a ruling of 4 February 2026, the ASA found that buyers would read "biodegradable baby wipes" to mean that the whole wipe biodegrades in normal disposal conditions, but the evidence covered only the viscose part under test conditions. It also treated "sustainable" as an absolute claim that needed evidence for the whole life cycle.33

Since 6 April 2025, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has been able to decide that a company has broken consumer law without going to court, and to fine it up to 10% of its global turnover. Green claims are among its enforcement priorities.34

11. Summary table

The table summarises sections 3 to 10. "Same" in the GB column means that the rule is the same as in the EU.

Claim EU Great Britain Proof to keep
"Organic" No legal definition; certification schemes such as COSMOS set thresholds No UK standard: name the standard, and do not call a whole range organic if only part is certified Certificate; organic percentage on each basis shown on the label
"Natural", "100% natural" No definition; in France, only with at least 95% natural ingredients; in a name, may be an environmental claim No definition; not "100% natural" with synthetic ingredients; never "natural, so safe" Origin of every ingredient; calculation method
"Vegan" No legal definition; may be an environmental claim or label if linked to the planet No legal definition Supplier statements on the source of every ingredient; certificate if a scheme's logo is used
"Cruelty-free", "not tested on animals" Can break the legal compliance criterion; Article 20(3) conditions if used; a brand's own badge may be a sustainability label Same, without the EU rule on sustainability labels Statements from every ingredient supplier; animal testing data
"Free from parabens" or another legal ingredient Not accepted in the Technical Document Unfair to legal ingredients; the ASA has upheld complaints against similar claims Do not use the claim
"Free from preservatives", "free from perfume" Only if no ingredient has that function Same Formula; supplier documents
"Chemical-free" Cannot be true Same Do not use the claim
"With argan oil", "20% laurel oil" The ingredient itself must be in the formula; a property claimed through it needs evidence, such as an effective concentration; in France a company paid a €200,000 settlement fine for highlighted ingredients at 0.01% Same Formula with percentages; effective concentration; test on the finished product for an effect
"Hypoallergenic" Only if designed to minimise the risk of allergy, without suggesting zero risk Same Allergen review of the formula; data on reactions after sale
"Dermatologically tested", "clinically tested" A study under a dermatologist or in a clinical setting Same Signed study report
"90% said…" A consumer test to best practice A consumer survey cannot support a measurable effect Protocol, results and statistics
"For eczema-prone skin", "treats acne", "heals" Medicinal claims are not allowed on cosmetics Medicinal claim: needs an MHRA authorisation Do not use the claim on a cosmetic
"Kills MRSA" on a hand product Medicinal claims are not allowed on cosmetics A named pathogen makes it a medicine; general germ claims are accepted for soaps, hand washes and hand gels; hand disinfectants are biocides Do not use the claim on a cosmetic
"For babies", "intimate wash", "sensitive skin" Part of what the safety report must assess; the claim must match it Same A safety report that covers this use
"Eco-friendly", "green", "biodegradable" Banned unless the product has the EU Ecolabel or an official type I ecolabel Evidence for the full life cycle; a high level of evidence for absolute claims Life-cycle evidence; ecolabel licence
A brand's own badge (leaf, rabbit) Banned unless based on a certification scheme, if buyers see it as a label A claim like any other: it must not suggest what the product does not have Certification documents

12. What to send for the safety report and the product information file

When the DGCCRF checked 147 new cosmetics businesses (section 9), only 26 had a complete or nearly complete product information file, and 26 had none (Figure 11). Some supported a "regenerating" claim with a sales website or Wikipedia, and nearly half had no safety report, or an incomplete one.27

About 60 of the businesses received injunctions or official reports, 56 received warnings, and 3 had their websites or social media accounts restricted or blocked.27

Product information files of 147 cosmetics businesses new to the sector, checked in France and published in February 2026, one square per business: 26 complete or nearly complete; 95 incomplete, inconsistent, not updated or dated after the product went on sale; 26 with no file. The safety report was missing or incomplete in nearly half of the businesses.

Figure 11. Each square is one of the 147 businesses that the DGCCRF checked.

Our article on the safety report for the EU and Great Britain lists the documents needed to start. For claims, send these with your formula:

  • every claim made for the product, wherever it appears: label and pack, marketplace listings such as Etsy, Amazon and eBay, your website and your social media, including posts that you pay others to make;
  • the proof that you hold for each claim: certificates, supplier statements, test or study reports, and calculations;
  • who the product is for: age group, part of the body, and whether it is for intimate use;
  • where you sell it: the EU, Great Britain or both.

Safety reports and testing from NorrChemica

Our safety report covers the EU and Great Britain: your formula is assessed against the rules of each market where you sell.

Cosmetics testing What the safety report includes

Sources

  1. Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products: Articles 2, 11, 18 and 20, and Annex I. EU version consolidated on 1 September 2025: eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2009/1223; GB version: legislation.gov.uk/eur/2009/1223
  2. Commission Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 laying down common criteria for the justification of claims used in relation to cosmetic products. EU version: eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2013/655/oj; GB version: legislation.gov.uk/eur/2013/655
  3. Office for Product Safety and Standards, Making cosmetic products available to consumers in Great Britain. gov.uk/guidance/making-cosmetic-products-available-to-consumers-in-great-britain
  4. Sub-Working Group on Claims, Technical document on cosmetic claims, version of 3 July 2017; Annexes III and IV apply from 1 July 2019. Copy published by the Croatian Ministry of Health, zdravlje.gov.hr
  5. CTPA, Cosmetic claims: focus on 'free from' claims, 3 July 2019; CTPA Help Note on 'free from' claims, 29 March 2019. ctpa.org.uk
  6. European Commission, Report on product claims made based on common criteria in the field of cosmetics, COM(2016) 580 final, 19 September 2016. data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/ST-12496-2016-INIT/en/pdf
  7. DGCCRF, Allégations sur les produits cosmétiques : tout n'est pas permis !, 17 November 2023 (checks carried out in 2021). economie.gouv.fr/dgccrf/allegations-sur-les-produits-cosmetiques-tout-nest-pas-permis
  8. ASA and CAP, AdviceOnline: Beauty and cosmetics: general; Beauty and cosmetics: creams; Organic: general; Hair care; Types of claims: safe; Animal testing and cosmetics. asa.org.uk/advice-online
  9. ASA, rulings database (searches for skincare, cosmetics and CAP Code rule 12.1), read 17 November 2026; ASA ruling of 5 November 2025 on an LED face mask (acne-related redness); ASA ruling A12-196408 (2012) on hair dye claims. asa.org.uk/codes-and-rulings/rulings.html
  10. CTPA, Claims, advertising and communication; CTPA, Claims resources. ctpa.org.uk/claims-advertising-communication and ctpa.org.uk/resources-claims
  11. ISO 16128-1:2016 and ISO 16128-2:2017, Guidelines on technical definitions and criteria for natural and organic cosmetic ingredients and products, scope and contents as published by ISO; ISO/TR 23750:2021, as summarised by Cosmed in Beauty Horizons, 2021. iso.org/standard/65197.html
  12. DGCCRF, Cosmétiques : à la recherche du « naturel », 12 March 2020 (checks carried out in 2019). economie.gouv.fr/dgccrf/cosmetiques-la-recherche-du-naturel
  13. European Commission, Directorate-General for Justice and Consumers, Questions & Answers on Directive (EU) 2024/825, version of 22 September 2026. commission.europa.eu
  14. COSMOS-standard AISBL, COSMOS-standard version 4.2 (sections 7 and 10) and Technical Guide version 4.2, 1 September 2025; Soil Association, Relevant changes in the COSMOS-standard V4.2, and Health and beauty standards page. cosmos-standard.org/en/documents
  15. The Vegan Society, Vegan Trademark Standards, and registration pages for cosmetics, household products and toiletries. vegansociety.com
  16. The Vegan Society, Vegan Beauty Takeover report, 2023 (revised), with a survey of 1,000 UK adults carried out with Attest in July 2023; The Vegan Society, Ten swaps to make your beauty routine kinder to animals. vegansociety.com
  17. DGCCRF, Cosmétiques : ne vous fiez pas à l'allégation « non testé sur les animaux » !, 11 June 2019, published on sante.fr. sante.fr/cosmetiques-ne-vous-fiez-pas-lallegation-non-teste-sur-les-animaux
  18. CTPA, Animal testing and cosmetic products. thefactsabout.co.uk
  19. CTPA, ASA ruling on 'free from' claims, 22 May 2023. ctpa.org.uk
  20. CTPA, ASA upholds CTPA complaint over misleading 'PPD-free' claims, 12 February 2025. ctpa.org.uk
  21. Consumer preferences, product characteristics, and potentially allergenic ingredients in best-selling moisturizers. JAMA Dermatology 2017;153(11):1099–1105. doi:10.1001/jamadermatol.2017.3046
  22. MHRA, Guidance Note 8: A guide to what is a medicinal product, version on gov.uk read 17 November 2026. assets.publishing.service.gov.uk
  23. Directive 2001/83/EC on the Community code relating to medicinal products for human use: Articles 1(2) and 2(2). eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2001/83
  24. CTPA, Cosmetic claims: MHRA position on adverse skin conditions, 19 October 2018. ctpa.org.uk
  25. CTPA, Cosmetic product borderlines; CTPA, Borderline focus: is my product a cosmetic?, 18 September 2020. ctpa.org.uk/borderlines
  26. Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, Annex V, entry 3 (salicylic acid), as amended by Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/1966, which applies in the EU and GB. eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2019/1966; legislation.gov.uk/eur/2019/1966
  27. DGCCRF, Cosmétiques : des TPE nouvelles dans le secteur qui méconnaissent trop souvent la réglementation, 2 February 2026. economie.gouv.fr/dgccrf/laction-de-la-dgccrf/les-enquetes-et-les-controles
  28. Directive (EU) 2024/825 amending Directives 2005/29/EC and 2011/83/EU as regards empowering consumers for the green transition. eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2024/825/oj
  29. Loyens & Loeff, ESG update: Green Claims Directive set to be withdrawn but anti-greenwashing rules remain, November 2026. loyensloeff.com
  30. Freshfields, EmpCo Directive: EU Member State implementation tracker, status as at 5 October 2026. freshfields.com/en/our-thinking/campaigns/empco-transposition-tracker
  31. CAP Code (UK Code of Non-broadcast Advertising and Direct & Promotional Marketing), section 11: Environmental claims. asa.org.uk
  32. ASA, Green disposal claims in advertising, 28 November 2023. asa.org.uk/news/green-disposal-claims-in-advertising.html
  33. ASA ruling of 4 February 2026 on environmental claims for nappies and baby wipes; CTPA, ASA rulings on environmental claims, 4 February 2026; RPC, Green claims update, spring 2026. asa.org.uk; ctpa.org.uk; rpclegal.com
  34. CMA, CMA to boost consumer and business confidence as new consumer protection regime comes into force, April 2025, gov.uk; KPMG, New consumer enforcement regime (Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024), 2025; Gordons, CMA's consumer law enforcement priorities and finalised guidance for businesses, 15 April 2025.

About this article. We read the sources on 17 November 2026. They include Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 and Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 in their EU versions on EUR-Lex and their GB versions on legislation.gov.uk, Directive 2001/83/EC and Directive (EU) 2024/825 on EUR-Lex, the EU Technical Document on Cosmetic Claims (version of 3 July 2017), the MHRA's Guidance Note 8, the Commission's report of 2016, the DGCCRF's published results from 2019 to 2026, the COSMOS standard (version 4.2), the US study of moisturisers and the Vegan Society's report. ISO 16128 is described from its published scope and summaries, because the standard itself is sold. The state of national laws comes from a law firm's tracker. The GB rulings come from the ASA's website, or from published summaries named as sources. Where the text gives our own reading of a rule, it says so. This article is not legal advice.

© 2026 NorrChemica. All rights reserved.
Content may not be reproduced without written permission.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Further reading

Cosmetics in Great Britain and the EU — an eight-part series

More in Analysis Notes.