Cosmetics recalls in the EU: why products are pulled from the market, and which of those reasons a test can catch
Share
Cosmetics recalls in the EU: why products are pulled from the market, and which of those reasons a test can catch
When a cosmetic product is recalled in the EU for a safety reason, the recall is published in a database called Safety Gate. We counted the cosmetics recalls by reason and by product type. The result is simple. Most recalls are for one banned perfume ingredient, and you find it by reading the label. The recalls for bacteria are almost all products that contain water, and one bacterium causes most of them. Heavy metals appear in one kind of product only.
1What Safety Gate is
Safety Gate is the EU alert system for dangerous products other than food. Until 2018 it was called RAPEX. When an authority in a member state finds a dangerous product, it reports it to the European Commission. The Commission publishes the report as an alert. Each alert gives the product, the brand, the batch, the country that reported it, the country where the product was made, the risk and the measure taken. Anyone can search the database, and the Commission publishes the yearly totals in a report.
The system covers the EU, Norway, Iceland and Liechtenstein. Great Britain left it at the end of 2020 and has its own database. A product recalled in Great Britain since 2021 does not appear in Safety Gate. Northern Ireland is still included.
Two things to remember when reading the numbers. First, an alert exists only because an authority tested a product and found a problem. A country that tests many shower gels will report many shower gels. So the numbers show what was found, not everything that is on sale. Second, one alert is one product and one batch, not one brand.
Sources 1, 2.
2The totals: cosmetics are the largest group, because of one ingredient
In 2025 the system recorded 4,671 alerts, the highest number since it started in 2003. Cosmetics were 36 % of them. Toys came second with 16 % and electrical equipment third with 11 %. In 2024 there were 4,137 alerts, and cosmetics were again 36 %.
One ingredient explains almost all of it. The Commission says that in 2025, almost eight in ten cosmetics alerts were for a perfume ingredient called BMHCA, also sold under the name Lilial. The EU banned it on 1 March 2022 because it can harm fertility and the unborn child. In 2024, 97 % of the chemical alerts for cosmetics were for this same ingredient. In 2023 it was the reason for 1,012 of the 1,098 cosmetics alerts.
Before the ban, BMHCA was in a large number of perfumed products. The products the authorities keep finding are of two kinds: old stock made before the ban, and imported products made with a recipe that was never changed after the ban. No laboratory is needed to find it. It is written on the ingredient list. A brand that reads its own recipe, and the paper its perfume supplier sends with the perfume, already knows whether it is there.
Sources 1, 3, 4.
The main reason cosmetics are recalled in the EU is a banned ingredient that is written on the label. No test is needed to find it. The first check is to read the recipe, and that check is free.
3The other reasons
The yearly reports do not say what the other cosmetics alerts are for. A scientific review published in 2026 did that work. It looked at 2,561 cosmetics alerts from 2005 to 2023 and sorted them by reason. In the group it studied in detail, 64 % were for a banned or restricted substance, 12 % for bacteria or fungi, and 5 % for heavy metals, meaning lead and mercury.
Before 2022, the banned substances were different ones. Skin-lightening creams contained hydroquinone and the steroid clobetasol. Hair-straightening products and nail hardeners contained formaldehyde. Creams and lotions contained the preservative methylisothiazolinone after it was banned in products that stay on the skin. And skin-lightening creams contained mercury. Of the skin-lightening products reported, 38 % contained hydroquinone and 20 % contained a heavy metal, mostly mercury.
Source 4.
In the recalls, heavy metals are a problem of skin-lightening creams, where mercury is added on purpose. For a soap, a balm or a face cream made in the EU, the recalls give no reason to test for heavy metals first.
4The microbiological recalls, product by product
We downloaded from the database every cosmetics alert of the last ten years marked "microbiological". There are 127, from 2016 to October 2026. Each record names the product, the country where it was made, the country that reported it, and the bacterium, yeast or mould that was found. We counted them ourselves, because this is the information a brand needs when it decides what to test.
Which products
| Product type | Alerts | Examples in the record |
|---|---|---|
| Rinse-off: shower gels, liquid soaps, shampoos, bath products, cleansers, micellar waters | 45 | shower gel (6), liquid hand soap (4), make-up remover (3), micellar water (2) |
| Leave-on: face creams, masks, eye creams, scalp and hair care, sunscreens, sprays | 34 | face cream (4), primer spray (3), sunscreen (3), eye cream (2) |
| Henna and hair colour | 12 | henna powder (5), hair dye (3) |
| Make-up and face paint | 11 | mascara (3), face paint (3), eye shadow, eyeliner, concealer, lip gloss |
| Wipes | 8 | wet wipes (5), baby wet wipes (2), skin cleansing wipes |
| Oral care | 7 | toothpaste (3), tooth powder (3), mouthwash (2) |
| Other | 10 | lip balm, body butter, baby powder, shaving kit, hair detangler |
Three things are clear from the table.
- Rinse-off products are the largest group, even though they are washed off in seconds. A shower gel is mostly water. It is opened every day and it lives in a warm, wet bathroom. The recalls show that the preservative does not always work.
- Wipes and mascaras appear again and again. Both contain water, and the user touches the product every time it is used.
- Henna powders, toothpastes and tooth powders are a different case. They are dry products that were already contaminated when they left the factory. Nearly all came from India or Pakistan and were caught when they entered the EU.
Which organisms
Of the 127 alerts, 68 name the organism that was found. The others say only that the total number of bacteria was above the limit, or that mould and yeast were found, or both.
| Organism | Alerts naming it | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| Pseudomonas aeruginosa | 28 | A bacterium that lives in water: taps, pipes, wet surfaces. It grows in products that contain water when the preservative is weak. It causes eye, skin and wound infections. It is one of the four organisms that COS-01 tests for by name. |
| Burkholderia cepacia and related species | 12 | Another water bacterium. Many preservatives and antibiotics do not kill it. It is dangerous for people with cystic fibrosis or a weak immune system. It is not one of the four named organisms; it is found through the total count. |
| Enterobacter, Pluralibacter gergoviae and related bacteria | 13 | Bacteria from the gut and from soil and water. P. gergoviae is known to survive in cosmetics that contain a preservative. They are found through the total count and the E. coli test. |
| Klebsiella | 5 | Same family as the line above; found the same way. |
| Staphylococcus aureus | 5 | A bacterium from human skin. Finding it means people contaminated the product while making or filling it. One of the four named organisms. |
| Candida albicans | 3 | A yeast. One of the four named organisms. |
| Mould and yeast, not named | 28 | Reported as a number only. Usually comes from the raw materials, the water, or a pack that lets air in. |
| Total count above the limit, no organism named | 77 | The product had more bacteria than the limit allows. This is the most common finding of all. |
We made these counts from the downloaded records (source 2). One alert can name more than one organism, so the column adds up to more than 127. A study from 2019 of the older RAPEX data found the same order: Pseudomonas first, and a total count over the limit as the reason in 89 % of cosmetics alerts (source 5).
The bacterium that gets water-containing cosmetics recalled is Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The finding that gets most of them recalled is a total count over the limit. The COS-01 microbiological purity test measures both.
5Two alerts that add to our previous article
Our previous article explained that products without water, such as balms, butters and oils, are a low microbiological risk, because nothing grows without water. The recalls agree. Of 127 microbiological alerts, only two are for products of this kind, and both teach something.
- A lip balm from China, 2023. It contained Staphylococcus aureus, yeast and moulds. Nothing grew in the balm afterwards; the balm was dirty when it was made. A low-risk recipe does not protect against a dirty factory. This is why the written justification for a low-risk product must also show that the product is made in clean conditions.
- A body butter from Spain, 2025. It was recalled after Pseudomonas aeruginosa grew in one batch. The alert gives the cause: "a loss of efficacy of the preservative in that batch", which means the preservative in that batch stopped working. A body butter that needs a preservative is a body butter that contains water. Once there is water in the recipe, the product needs the challenge test, whatever its name says.
Source 2, alerts A12/02662/23 and SR/04402/25.
Low risk means the product will not get worse after it is made. It does not mean the product starts clean. And it no longer applies once water enters the recipe.
6Which of these reasons a test can catch
| Reason for the alert | How common | How to find it | Laboratory test |
|---|---|---|---|
| BMHCA and other banned ingredients that were added on purpose | most cosmetics alerts since 2022 | read the recipe and the papers from the perfume supplier | none needed. An ingredient analysis only if you do not trust the supplier |
| Bacteria, yeast and mould | about one alert in eight before 2022; a smaller share now, because the BMHCA alerts are so many | count the bacteria in the finished product and test for the four named organisms; the challenge test shows whether the preservative keeps working after the product is opened | COS-01; COS-02 for products that contain water and are opened and used |
| Hydroquinone, clobetasol, mercury in skin-lightening products | one kind of product | the recipe, if you make the product; a laboratory analysis, if you import it | analysis for the named substance, on request |
| No responsible person, no safety report, wrong labelling | not counted as a hazard, but the reason behind many alerts | check the product information file | none |
For a small brand in the EU that makes products containing water, the recalls point to one test first: the microbiological purity of the finished product. The reasons that come before it in the alert count are paperwork, and paperwork is free.
Cosmetics testing from NorrChemica
Our cosmetics testing page lists the microbiological purity test (COS-01), the challenge test (COS-02) and the stability test (COS-03), with prices and the sample to send. If you are not sure which of them your product needs, tell us what you make. We will tell you, free of charge.
Request testing → Cosmetics testing: packages and prices Which test answers which question Which products need fewer testsSources
- European Commission, "Commission's 2025 Safety Gate Report shows increased action against dangerous products and stronger consumer protection", press release, 5 March 2026: 4,671 alerts; cosmetics 36 %, toys 16 %, electrical appliances 11 %; "almost eight in 10 alerts concerning cosmetics related to the presence of BMHCA". europa.eu. For 2024: 4,137 alerts, cosmetics 36 %, 97 % of chemical cosmetics alerts for BMHCA, as summarised by SGS, 31 July 2025. sgs.com
- European Commission, Safety Gate alert database, search for product category "Cosmetics" and risk type "Microbiological", alerts of the last ten years, exported to a spreadsheet on 24 October 2026: 127 records. ec.europa.eu/safety-gate-alerts
- Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/1902 of 29 October 2021, which added butylphenyl methylpropional to Annex II of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 with effect from 1 March 2022. EUR-Lex
- "Potential side effects of toxic and restricted substances found in cosmetics declared to be of natural origin", Frontiers in Public Health, 20 May 2026, doi:10.3389/fpubh.2026.1801090: 2,561 Safety Gate cosmetics reports 2005–2023; unauthorised substances 64 %, microbial contamination 12 %, heavy metals 5 %; BMHCA in 1,012 of 1,098 notifications in 2023; hydroquinone 38 % and heavy metals 20 % of skin-lightening products. frontiersin.org
- "Microbiological Safety of Non-Food Products: What Can We Learn from the RAPEX Database?", International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2019, 16(9), 1599, doi:10.3390/ijerph16091599: RAPEX 2005–2017, 111 cosmetics notifications, Pseudomonas aeruginosa the most frequent organism, total aerobic count above the limit the reason in 89 % of cosmetics notifications. mdpi.com
About this article
The 2025 and 2024 totals are the Commission's own figures. We read them in the press release of 5 March 2026 and in a summary of the 2024 report; we did not read the 2024 report itself. The counts in sections 4 and 5 are ours, made on 24 October 2026 from the records we downloaded from the public database that day; they will change as alerts are added. The two journal articles were read in full. Safety Gate records what authorities found and reported, not everything on sale. This article is not legal advice; we will date any future revisions.
© 2026 NorrChemica™ · Content may not be reproduced without written permission