Water activity scale from 0.5 to 1.0 with the 0.75 low-risk threshold marked: balms, oils, bar soap and bath bombs on the left, creams, lotions and liquid soap on the right.

Soap, balms, oils, bath bombs and alcohol-based products: which laboratory tests do they really need?

Analysis Notes · Cosmetics

Soap, balms, oils, bath bombs and alcohol-based products: which laboratory tests do they really need?

A cream or a shampoo needs a microbiological test and a challenge test before it is sold. A bar of soap, a balm or a perfume may need neither, because micro-organisms cannot grow in them. This article explains which properties of a product make it a low microbiological risk, where the thresholds come from, which of the products small brands make most often qualify, and what the safety assessor needs in writing instead of a test result.

1The rule


The EU Cosmetics Regulation requires a safety report for every cosmetic product, and the report must state the microbiological quality of the product. The Commission guidelines on the safety report divide products into three groups. Products of low microbiological risk need neither a challenge test nor a microbiological test of the finished product; a scientific justification must be written instead. Single-use products and products in a pack that cannot be opened need the microbiological test only, again with a written justification. All other products need both tests. Great Britain applies the same text, and Northern Ireland follows the EU rules.

The guidelines give three examples of the low-risk group: products with more than 20 % alcohol, products based on organic solvents, and products with a high or low pH. They give no figure for the pH and say nothing about water. The safety assessor decides which group a product belongs to, and the responsible person must be able to show the reasoning.

Sources 1, 2, 5.

Our previous article, Cosmetics testing: is it clean, does the preservative work, and does it stay stable in its pack?, explains the three groups and our four packages. This article is about the first group.

A product is low-risk because of what it is made of, not because it contains a preservative. The justification needs numbers.

2Where the thresholds come from


The guidelines refer to the Notes of Guidance of the SCCS, the Commission's scientific committee for consumer safety. The SCCS states that the challenge test is mandatory for every product that may deteriorate or put the consumer at risk of infection under normal storage and use, and that no legal or universal method exists.

The standard that laboratories and safety assessors use to identify a low-risk product is ISO 29621, Guidelines for the risk assessment and identification of microbiologically low-risk products. We have read its public summary and table of contents, not the standard itself. The thresholds below are those reported, in the same terms, by laboratories and regulatory consultancies that work with it. Each is a figure a brand can measure or calculate for its own product.

Property of the formula Threshold reported from ISO 29621 Why it stops microbial growth
Water activity (aw) at most 0.75 Micro-organisms need free water. A product with no water, or with its water bound by salt, sugar or glycerine, does not supply it.
pH at most 3, or at least 10 A strongly acidic or strongly alkaline product forces the cell to spend its energy on keeping its internal pH instead of growing.
Alcohol (ethanol) at least 20 % Ethanol at this level damages cell membranes and proteins.
Packaging single use, or a pack that lets nothing in The product is clean when filled and nothing enters afterwards. This is the second group of the guidelines, which still needs the microbiological test.
Combined factors no single threshold Two or three properties, each short of its threshold, can together make a hostile environment. The brand must show the evidence.

Sources 3, 4, 6, 7.

Water activity

Water activity is not the water content. It is the ratio between the water vapour pressure of the product and that of pure water at the same temperature, on a scale from 0 to 1. Pure water is 1.0, and a cream is close to it. A jam is about 0.8, because its sugar binds the water. Dried fruit is about 0.6. An oil, a wax or a dry powder is far below that. Food microbiology has measured the lowest water activity at which each group of organisms grows, and those figures are the basis of the cosmetics threshold.

Water activity: where micro-organisms stop growing 0.60: below this, nothing grows most bacteria grow from 0.91 most yeasts grow from 0.88 most moulds grow from 0.80 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 0.75 low-risk threshold reported from ISO 29621 creams, lotions, hydrosols, liquid soap: 0.95 to 1.0 jam: about 0.8 dried fruit: about 0.6 oils, waxes, balms, bar soap, dry powders: well below 0.6
Lowest water activity at which most bacteria, yeasts and moulds grow, and where common products sit on the scale. Growth limits from food-safety references (sources 6, 7); the 0.75 threshold as reported from ISO 29621 (sources 3, 4). Product positions are typical values, not measurements of any particular product.

0.75 is a cautious threshold: most bacteria stop at 0.91 and most moulds at 0.80. A product with no water in its formula is far below it.

3Product by product


The products below are the ones small brands make most often. For each we give the documented facts, then our reading. The assessor's decision is final.

Bar soap, cold process or hot process

A cured bar has a low water content and a high pH. A survey of 64 commercial bars found 53 of them between pH 9 and 10 when measured in solution. That is close to the reported threshold of 10 but often just below it, so a bar does not always qualify on pH alone. It qualifies on the combination of high pH and low water activity, and the assessor will want both figures: the pH of your own bar, and the water content or water activity of the cured bar. Melt-and-pour bases are in the same position, and the supplier's data sheet often gives the pH.

Our reading: a cured bar is a low-risk product with a short justification. Liquid soap is a different product; see section 4.

Sources 3, 4, 8.

Balms, salves, body butters, lip balms, oils and oil serums

These products contain no water. Their water activity is close to zero, against a threshold of 0.75, and laboratories name body oils, lip balms and lipsticks as the standard examples of the low-risk group. Products poured hot into their pack are also named, because the fill temperature kills what the ingredients brought in.

Two things change the position. If the formula contains any water-based ingredient (a hydrosol, aloe juice, an extract in water), the product is no longer anhydrous and the water activity must be measured. If the product is used with wet fingers from an open tin, water enters during use; the guidelines count contamination in use as part of the risk, and this is a point for the assessor.

Our reading: an anhydrous balm, butter or oil is a low-risk product. The justification states that the formula contains no water and lists every ingredient with its function, so that the assessor can see that none of them brings water in.

Sources 2, 3, 4, 9.

Bath bombs, bath salts and dry scrubs

A bath bomb is a pressed powder of bicarbonate, citric acid and additives; a bath salt is a salt. Both have a very low water activity as sold, and both dissolve in the bath at the moment of use. Powders and salts are not named in the guidelines or in the lists we have seen, so the argument rests on the water-activity criterion and on the single-use pattern. Humidity is the weak point: a powder stored open in a bathroom takes up water, so the justification should state how the product is packed.

A scrub of oil with sugar or salt is also anhydrous as sold, but it is used in the shower, with wet hands, from a jar. Once water is in the jar, the sugar or salt dissolves and the water activity rises. We would expect an assessor either to ask for a challenge test or to accept a justification based on the pack (a tube or a pump rather than an open jar).

Our reading: bath bombs and bath salts, packed dry, are low-risk products. A scrub in an open jar is a case for the assessor, and the pack decides it.

Sources 2, 3, 4, 6.

Perfumes, colognes, toners and other alcohol-based products

This is the one example the guidelines give with a number: an alcohol content above 20 %. A perfume or an eau de cologne is far above it. A toner, a facial mist or a hair tonic qualifies only if the ethanol in the final formula is 20 % or more. Many are made at 5 to 15 %; those are water-based products with a little alcohol, and they belong to the third group. The percentage in the formula is the evidence.

Hydrosols and floral waters sold on their own are water with traces of oil and no alcohol. They are among the highest-risk products a small brand can sell, and they need both tests unless the pack cannot be opened.

Our reading: 20 % ethanol in the final product, documented in the formula, is enough. Below that figure, treat the product as water-based.

Sources 2, 3.

Strongly acidic products

The reported threshold is pH 3 or below. Exfoliating products with glycolic or lactic acid sometimes reach it, but most consumer products are formulated above pH 3.5 for the skin's sake, and they then fall in the third group. A pH measurement of the finished product settles it.

Sources 3, 4.

4Products that look low-risk but are not


  • Liquid soap and shower gel. A liquid soap made with potassium hydroxide has a pH of about 9 to 10 and is mostly water. Its pH is below the threshold and its water activity is high. Both tests.
  • Whipped butters and lotion bars with aloe, hydrosol or any water. One water-based ingredient turns an anhydrous product into an emulsion. Both tests.
  • Toners and mists at 5 to 15 % alcohol. Below 20 %, alcohol is an ingredient, not a preservation system. Both tests.
  • Hydrosols and floral waters. Water. Both tests.
  • Sugar scrubs in open jars used in the shower. Dry as sold, wet in use. The assessor decides, and the pack is the argument.
  • Any product with a preservative added "to be safe". A preservative does not make a product low-risk; it makes it a product whose preservative must be shown to work, which is what the challenge test is for.

Sources 2, 3, 4, 8.

The question is not "does it contain a preservative?" but "can anything grow in it?". Water, at a pH between 3 and 10 and with less than 20 % alcohol, means yes.

5What the written justification contains


The guidelines say that the absence of test data must be justified in Part A of the safety report and that the safety assessor repeats and validates the justification in Part B. They do not say what the justification must contain. The list below is general practice, not a requirement of the texts.

  • The property the product relies on, with its value: the pH of the finished product and how it was measured; the water content or water activity; the ethanol percentage in the final formula; the fill temperature if the product is poured hot.
  • The full formula with the function of each ingredient. The report needs it in any case, and it lets the assessor see that no ingredient brings water, nutrients or a neutral pH into the product.
  • The pack and the way the product is used, because the risk the guidelines describe includes contamination during use.
  • A statement of good manufacturing practice, which the product information file must contain in any case. Low risk means the product will not get worse; it does not mean it starts clean. A product filled from dirty equipment is contaminated whatever its pH.
  • The reference used for the threshold, in practice ISO 29621 or the SCCS Notes of Guidance.

Sources 1, 2, 3.

A measured pH, a measured or calculated water activity and the formula are the three documents the assessor needs. Measure them before you send the formula, not after the assessor asks.

6What a laboratory can still do for a low-risk product


The low-risk group is exempt from the microbiological tests only. The other results the safety report needs are the same for every product.

  • Stability. The report must describe how the minimum durability was set and give the data, for every product. A balm that goes rancid, a bath bomb that fizzes in its wrapper or a bar that sweats in a warm room are stability questions. The method is for the manufacturer to choose and describe. Our COS-03 stability and packaging compatibility package is one way to produce the data; a documented study of your own is another.
  • Microbiological purity of one batch. Not required for a low-risk product, but a single COS-01 microbiological purity result on the first batch is the simplest evidence that the product starts clean, and some assessors ask for it. It costs €79 per product.
  • A pH measurement. We measure the pH of the finished product within COS-03 where it applies. If you need only the pH figure for a justification, ask; we will quote it on its own.

The challenge test is the one result a low-risk product can do without. COS-02 costs €250 and takes 25 to 35 working days, so it is worth asking your assessor whether the justification is enough before you order it. Some assessors still prefer a test result to a written argument, and in that case the test is the quicker route to a signed report.

For a bar of soap, a balm or a perfume, start with stability and, if the assessor wants it, one purity test. Order the challenge test when the assessor asks for it, not by default.

7One table to keep


Product Property that makes it low-risk Evidence for the justification Likely group Laboratory results
Bar soap, cold or hot process; melt-and-pour high pH (about 9 to 10 in solution) and low water activity together pH of your bar; water content or aw of the cured bar low risk stability; COS-01 if the assessor asks
Balm, salve, body butter, lip balm, oil no water: aw near zero formula with no water-based ingredient; fill temperature if hot-poured low risk stability; COS-01 if the assessor asks
Bath bomb, bath salt, dry powder dry: low aw; dissolved at use formula; pack that keeps moisture out low risk stability
Perfume, cologne, alcohol-based toner ethanol at least 20 % of the final formula the formula low risk stability
Acid exfoliant at pH 3 or below low pH pH of the finished product low risk stability
Scrub of oil with sugar or salt, open jar, used wet dry as sold only pack and pattern of use assessor decides COS-02, or a justification based on the pack
Liquid soap, shower gel, lotion, cream, hydrosol, toner below 20 % alcohol none — all other products COS-02 and stability, or COS-04
Single-dose sachet or airless pump of any of the above pack lets nothing in pack specification single use or cannot be opened COS-01 and stability

"Likely group" is our reading of the guidelines and of the thresholds reported from ISO 29621. The safety assessor makes the decision.

Cosmetics testing from NorrChemica

If your product is on this page, tell us what it is and what your safety assessor has asked for. We will tell you which results you need and which you do not, free of charge. Every package is listed on our cosmetics testing page with its price and the sample to send.

Request testing → Cosmetics testing: packages and prices The three groups and the four packages
Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Further reading

Cosmetics in Great Britain and the EU — an eight-part series

More in Analysis Notes.