Cosmetic preservatives in the EU and Great Britain — NorrChemica Analysis Notes, Cosmetics Series, Part 8. Navy card with 55 dots, one for the maximum of each EU entry, from 0.0015% for isothiazolinones to 2.5% for benzoic acid in rinse-off products.

Cosmetic preservatives in the EU and Great Britain: every allowed preservative and its limit, which ones depend on pH, and why a product fails the challenge test

Analysis Notes · Cosmetics Series · Part 8

Cosmetic preservatives in the EU and Great Britain: every allowed preservative and its limit, which ones depend on pH, and why a product fails the challenge test

All 55 entries of the EU list and the 125 ingredients they name, the 54 entries of the GB list, where the two lists differ, and which preservatives 23,922 products list.

MARKETS EU · NORTHERN IRELAND · GREAT BRITAINLIST ANNEX V · EU 55 · GB 54RULES AS AT 19 NOV 2026

In the EU and Great Britain (GB), a cosmetic may contain only the preservatives listed in Annex V of the Cosmetics Regulation, each up to its maximum and under its conditions.1

1. One list in each market

The rule is in Article 14 of the Cosmetics Regulation.1 GB kept the regulation after Brexit and amends its own list by statutory instrument, while Northern Ireland follows the EU list (Part 5 of this series).

  • The EU list has 55 entries. This version has applied since 18 May 2026, and EUR-Lex lists no later amendment.1,2
  • The GB list has 54 entries. legislation.gov.uk lists no amendment that its text does not yet include.1
  • 50 entries are the same in both lists, and five differ (section 7).

The 55 entries name 125 ingredients, with 134 CAS numbers, because one entry can cover several substances. Entry 1a, for example, names 12 salts and esters of benzoic acid, and entry 44 names seven conditioning agents. Entries that say ‘and its salts’ also cover other salts, which the annex defines at its start.1 The entry numbers run to 61 because eight entries have been deleted or moved.

Bar chart of the number of ingredient names in the 18 entries of the EU preservative list that name more than one, from 12 for entry 1a (other benzoate salts and esters) and 10 for entry 12 (methyl- and ethylparaben, their acid and salts) to 2 for six entries. The other 37 entries name one ingredient each: 125 names in total.

Figure 1. Our count of the names and CAS numbers in the EU text.1

The lists of allowed preservatives in China, Japan and ASEAN have about 50 entries each, and the United States has no such list.

Market List of allowed preservatives Size
EU and Northern Ireland Annex V of Regulation (EC) No 1223/20091 55 entries
Great Britain Annex V of the GB version of the regulation1 54 entries
China Safety and Technical Standards for Cosmetics, 2015 edition3,4 51 in 2015; ethyl lauroyl arginate HCl added in 2020
Japan Standards for Cosmetics, Appendix 35 48 entries: 16 for all cosmetics and 32 by product type
ASEAN ASEAN Cosmetic Directive, Annex VI, version of 22 June 20266 53 entries
United States No list: cosmetic ingredients other than colour additives need no FDA approval7 —

Entries as each list numbers them; one entry can cover several substances. The lists are not the same: Japan’s, for example, includes phenol, thymol and zinc pyrithione, which the EU list does not.

2. Which substances are preservatives

The regulation defines preservatives as substances used only or mainly to stop micro-organisms from growing in the product.1 So an ingredient that is not in the list may be used when it is added mainly for another purpose, even if it also protects the product (section 6).

A listed preservative that is added for another purpose must still meet the conditions of its entry, unless another annex covers that use.1 Footnotes to the list name such uses for nine entries, among them salicylic acid, benzyl alcohol and the -trimonium conditioning agents. Each of these nine also has an entry in Annex III, the list of restricted substances.

3. How to read an entry

Diagram of Annex V entry 12a, propylparaben and butylparaben, with its nine columns a to i. Columns a to e identify the substances. Column g gives the maximum: 0.14 percent as acid for the two together, and 0.8 percent for mixtures with entry 12. Column h: not in leave-on products for the nappy area of children under three. Column i: the label warning Do not use on the nappy area.

Figure 2. Source: Annex V.1

The maximum in column g is the concentration in the finished product, whichever raw material the preservative comes from.

For the acids, the maximum is given ‘as acid’. A salt weighs more than the acid it contains, so the same maximum allows a higher percentage of the salt.

Maximum as the salt, for every salt named in the acid entries

Salt Entry Maximum as the acid Factor Maximum as the salt
Sodium benzoate 1 Rinse-off, except oral: 2.5%
Oral products: 1.7%
Leave-on: 0.5%
1.180 Rinse-off, except oral: 2.95%
Oral products: 2.01%
Leave-on: 0.59%
Ammonium benzoate 1a 0.5% 1.139 0.57%
Calcium benzoate 1a 0.5% 1.156 0.58%
Potassium benzoate 1a 0.5% 1.312 0.66%
Magnesium benzoate 1a 0.5% 1.091 0.55%
MEA-benzoate 1a 0.5% 1.500 0.75%
Ammonium propionate 2 2% 1.230 2.46%
Calcium propionate 2 2% 1.257 2.51%
Magnesium propionate 2 2% 1.150 2.30%
Potassium propionate 2 2% 1.514 3.03%
Sodium propionate 2 2% 1.297 2.59%
Calcium salicylate 3 0.5% 1.138 0.57%
Magnesium salicylate 3 0.5% 1.081 0.54%
MEA-salicylate 3 0.5% 1.442 0.72%
Sodium salicylate 3 0.5% 1.159 0.58%
Potassium salicylate 3 0.5% 1.276 0.64%
TEA-salicylate 3 0.5% 2.080 1.04%
Calcium sorbate 4 0.6% 1.170 0.70%
Sodium sorbate 4 0.6% 1.196 0.72%
Potassium sorbate 4 0.6% 1.340 0.80%
Sodium dehydroacetate 13 0.6% 1.131 0.68%
Sodium formate 14 0.5% 1.478 0.74%
Potassium undecylenate 18 0.2% 1.207 0.24%
Sodium undecylenate 18 0.2% 1.119 0.22%
Calcium undecylenate 18 0.2% 1.103 0.22%
TEA-undecylenate 18 0.2% 1.810 0.36%
MEA-undecylenate 18 0.2% 1.331 0.27%

Maximum as the salt = maximum as the acid × factor. Factor = molar mass of the salt ÷ molar mass of the acid it contains; the calcium and magnesium salts contain two acid units. Example: sodium benzoate in a leave-on product, 0.5% × 144.10 ÷ 122.12 = 0.59%. The molar masses are those of the anhydrous salts; a hydrate allows a higher percentage. Values are rounded to two decimals. Entry 1a also covers seven esters of benzoic acid, at 0.5% as the acid.1

4. Every preservative in the list, by family

The tables group the entries by chemical family. The list itself has no families, so the grouping is ours.

Dot chart of the maximum of each of the 55 entries of the EU preservative list, grouped by family, on a logarithmic scale from 0.001 to 3 percent. The isothiazolinones (entries 39 and 57) have the lowest maximum, 0.0015 percent; benzoic acid and sodium benzoate in rinse-off products the highest, 2.5 percent, then propionic acid at 2 percent.

Figure 3. Logarithmic scale.1 In the GB list, entry 61 is absent and triclosan (entry 25) is also allowed in mouthwash at 0.2%.

The maximums range from 0.0015% for the isothiazolinones to 2.5% for benzoic acid in rinse-off products, a factor of more than 1,600.

The last column of each table names the product types in which the entry appears most often in Open Beauty Facts8 (section 5). Entries marked * also have other uses in Annex III, and their counts include those uses. Entries marked † differ in GB (section 7).

Organic acids and their salts: 8 entries

Their activity depends on the pH (section 8).

On the label Entry Maximum in the product Conditions and label warnings Most often found in
Benzoic Acid, Sodium Benzoate 1 Rinse-off, except oral: 2.5%. Oral products: 1.7%. Leave-on: 0.5% (all as acid) — Shampoo, shower gel and bath, cream or lotion7,247 products
Ammonium, Calcium, Magnesium, Potassium and MEA-Benzoate; Methyl, Ethyl, Propyl, Isopropyl, Butyl, Isobutyl and Phenyl Benzoate 1a 0.5% (as acid) — Cream or lotion, shampoo, shower gel and bath40 products
Propionic Acid; Ammonium, Calcium, Magnesium, Potassium and Sodium Propionate 2 2% (as acid) — 5 products
Salicylic Acid; Calcium, Magnesium, Potassium, Sodium, MEA- and TEA-Salicylate 3 * 0.5% (as acid) Acid: not in products for children under 3, not in oral products, and not in uses that may expose the lungs by inhalation. Salts: not in products for children under 3, except shampoos. Label, where the entry requires it: ‘Not to be used for children under 3 years of age’. Shampoo, cream or lotion, shower gel and bath1,391 products
Sorbic Acid; Calcium, Potassium and Sodium Sorbate 4 0.6% (as acid) — Cream or lotion, shampoo, shower gel and bath3,726 products
Dehydroacetic Acid, Sodium Dehydroacetate 13 0.6% (as acid) Not in aerosol sprays. Cream or lotion, shampoo, make-up764 products
Formic Acid, Sodium Formate 14 0.5% (as acid) — Shampoo, shower gel and bath, soap106 products
Undecylenic Acid; Calcium, Potassium, Sodium, MEA- and TEA-Undecylenate 18 0.2% (as acid) — 4 products

Parabens: 2 entries

On the label Entry Maximum in the product Conditions and label warnings Most often found in
Methylparaben, Ethylparaben, 4-Hydroxybenzoic Acid, and their sodium, potassium and calcium salts 12 One ester: 0.4%. Mixtures of esters: 0.8% (as acid) — Cream or lotion, make-up934 products
Propylparaben, Butylparaben, and their sodium and potassium salts 12a 0.14% for the two together; 0.8% for mixtures with entry 12 (as acid) Not in leave-on products for the nappy area of children under 3. Label on leave-on products for children under 3: ‘Do not use on the nappy area’. Cream or lotion, make-up538 products

Alcohols and glycol ethers: 6 entries

On the label Entry Maximum in the product Conditions and label warnings Most often found in
Chlorobutanol 11 0.5% Not in aerosol sprays. Label: ‘Contains Chlorobutanol’. 1 product
Dichlorobenzyl Alcohol 22 0.15% — 6 products
Phenoxyethanol 29 1% — Cream or lotion, make-up, shampoo5,725 products
Benzyl Alcohol 34 * 1% — Cream or lotion, shampoo, deodorant3,731 products
Phenoxyisopropanol 43 * Rinse-off products only: 1% — 2 products
Chlorphenesin 50 0.3% — Cream or lotion, sun care432 products

Formaldehyde releasers: 7 entries

The UK Scientific Advisory Group on Chemical Safety names these seven entries as examples of formaldehyde releasers.9 The warning ‘releases formaldehyde’ applies to products that contain them (section 7).

On the label Entry Maximum in the product Conditions and label warnings Most often found in
2-Bromo-2-Nitropropane-1,3-Diol (bronopol) 21 0.1% Avoid formation of nitrosamines. Cream or lotion, shampoo, shower gel and bath51 products
Imidazolidinyl Urea 27 0.6% — Cream or lotion, shampoo, conditioner and hair care72 products
Methenamine 30 0.15% — Not found
DMDM Hydantoin 33 0.6% — Shampoo, cream or lotion, shower gel and bath333 products
Diazolidinyl Urea 46 0.5% — Cream or lotion, shampoo134 products
Sodium Hydroxymethylglycinate 51 † 0.5% The formaldehyde that can be released from all sources must be below 0.1%. EU: the company must be able to show this. 13 products
Benzylhemiformal 55 Rinse-off products only: 0.15% — Not found

Isothiazolinones: 2 entries

On the label Entry Maximum in the product Conditions and label warnings Most often found in
Methylchloroisothiazolinone (and) Methylisothiazolinone 39 Rinse-off products only: 0.0015% of the 3:1 mixture Not in the same product as entry 57. Shampoo, conditioner and hair care, shower gel and bath937 products
Methylisothiazolinone 57 Rinse-off products only: 0.0015% Not in the same product as entry 39. Shampoo, cream or lotion, shower gel and bath231 products

Quaternary ammonium compounds, biguanides and amidines: 7 entries

On the label Entry Maximum in the product Conditions and label warnings Most often found in
Dibromohexamidine Isethionate 15 0.1% — Not found
Polyaminopropyl Biguanide 28 0.1% Not in uses that may expose the lungs by inhalation. Make-up, wipes, cream or lotion45 products
Chlorhexidine, Chlorhexidine Diacetate, Chlorhexidine Digluconate, Chlorhexidine Dihydrochloride 42 0.3% (as chlorhexidine) — Cream or lotion, conditioner and hair care, shampoo200 products
Behentrimonium Chloride, Cetrimonium Bromide, Cetrimonium Chloride, Laurtrimonium Bromide, Laurtrimonium Chloride, Steartrimonium Bromide, Steartrimonium Chloride 44 * 0.1% — Conditioner and hair care, shampoo, cream or lotion1,203 products
Hexamidine, Hexamidine Diisethionate, Hexamidine Paraben 47 0.1% — 2 products
Benzethonium Chloride 53 Rinse-off products, and leave-on products other than oral: 0.1% — 13 products
Benzalkonium Chloride, Benzalkonium Bromide, Benzalkonium Saccharinate 54 * 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) Label: ‘Avoid contact with eyes’. Cream or lotion, wipes, make-up67 products

Phenols and chlorinated aromatics: 7 entries

On the label Entry Maximum in the product Conditions and label warnings Most often found in
o-Phenylphenol; Sodium o-Phenylphenate (EU only) 7 † Rinse-off: 0.2%. Leave-on: 0.15% (as phenol; in the EU, for the two together) EU: not in uses that may expose the lungs by inhalation, and not in oral products. Label: ‘Avoid contact with eyes’. Not found
Triclocarban 23 * † 0.2%. EU: all products except mouthwash Two impurities (tetrachloroazobenzene, tetrachloroazoxybenzene) 1 ppm or less each. EU: not in toothpaste for children under 6; toothpaste label ‘Not to be used for children under 6 years of age’. 4 products
p-Chloro-m-Cresol (chlorocresol) 24 0.2% Not in products applied on mucous membranes. 1 product
Triclosan 25 † 0.3% in toothpaste, hand soap, body soap and shower gel, non-spray deodorant, face powder and blemish concealer, and nail-cleaning products used before artificial nails EU: not in toothpaste for children under 3; toothpaste label ‘Not to be used for children under 3 years of age’. Deodorant, soap, toothpaste49 products
Chloroxylenol 26 0.5% — 4 products
Bromochlorophene 37 0.1% — 1 product
o-Cymen-5-ol 38 0.1% — Cream or lotion, sun care, toothpaste56 products

Silver and mercury compounds: 5 entries

On the label Entry Maximum in the product Conditions and label warnings Most often found in
Thimerosal 16 Eye products only: 0.007% (as mercury), also for mixtures with entry 17 Label: ‘Contains Thiomersal’. Not found
Phenyl Mercuric Acetate, Phenyl Mercuric Benzoate 17 Eye products only: 0.007% (as mercury), also for mixtures with entry 16 Label: ‘Contains Phenylmercuric compounds’. Not found
Silver Chloride (20% on titanium dioxide) 52 0.004% (as silver chloride) Not in products for children under 3, oral products, or eye and lip products. 7 products
Citric Acid (and) Silver Citrate 59 0.2% (0.0024% silver) Not in oral or eye products. 5 products
Ammonium Silver Zinc Aluminium Silicate 61 † EU only: spray deodorant and powder foundation, 1% Silver content of the ingredient 2.5% or less. Not found

Other preservatives: 11 entries

On the label Entry Maximum in the product Conditions and label warnings Most often found in
Sodium Sulfite, Sodium Bisulfite, Sodium Metabisulfite, Potassium Sulfite, Potassium Hydrogen Sulfite, Potassium Metabisulfite, Ammonium Sulfite, Ammonium Bisulfite 9 * 0.2% (as free SO₂) — Hair colour, cream or lotion, shampoo353 products
Hexetidine 19 0.1% — Not found
5-Bromo-5-Nitro-1,3-Dioxane 20 Rinse-off products only: 0.1% Avoid formation of nitrosamines. Shampoo, shower gel and bath10 products
Climbazole 32 * Hair lotions, face creams and foot care products: 0.2%. Rinse-off shampoo: 0.5% — Shampoo34 products
Piroctone Olamine 35 Rinse-off: 1%. Other products: 0.5% — Shampoo, cream or lotion291 products
Dimethyl Oxazolidine 45 0.1% Only if the pH of the product is above 6. 1 product
Glutaral 48 0.1% Not in aerosol sprays. Label above 0.05%: ‘Contains glutaral’. 7 products
7-Ethylbicyclooxazolidine 49 0.3% Not in oral products or products applied on mucous membranes. Not found
Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate 56 Rinse-off: 0.02%. Leave-on: 0.01%. Deodorants and antiperspirants: 0.0075% Not in oral or lip products. Leave-on: not in body lotion or body cream. Not in products for children under 3, except bath products, shower gels and shampoo. Label: ‘Not to be used for children under 3 years of age’ where the entry requires it. Cream or lotion, shower gel and bath, deodorant142 products
Ethyl Lauroyl Arginate HCl 58 * Mouthwash: 0.15%. Other products: 0.4% Mouthwash: not for children under 10, with a label warning. Other products: not in lip products, oral products other than mouthwash, or sprays. 7 products
Hydroxyethoxyphenyl Butanone 60 0.7% — 1 product

5. Which preservatives products list

Open Beauty Facts is an open database of cosmetic products and their ingredient lists.8 In its export of 19 November 2026, 23,922 of its 80,769 products have an ingredient list, and 14,666 of these (61%) list at least one substance from Annex V. For each entry, we counted the products that list one of its names, and we gave each product a type from its category and name.

The counts show where a name appears in this database. They are not market shares, and the database includes products from many years and countries.

Bar chart of the ten entries of the EU preservative list found most often in Open Beauty Facts: benzoic acid and sodium benzoate 7,247 products, phenoxyethanol 5,725, benzyl alcohol 3,731, sorbic acid and its salts 3,726, salicylic acid and its salts 1,391, cetrimonium, behentrimonium and others 1,203, MCI/MI 937, methyl- and ethylparaben 934, dehydroacetic acid and its salt 764, and propyl- and butylparaben 538.

Figure 4. Data: Open Beauty Facts.8

Figures 5 to 7 leave out the nine entries with other uses in Annex III (section 2), because a product may list them for another purpose.

Heat map of the share of products of each type in Open Beauty Facts that list each of the ten preservative entries found most often. Highest shares: benzoate in wipes, shower gel, shampoo and mouthwash; phenoxyethanol in conditioner, cream or lotion, make-up and sun care.

Figure 5. MCI/MI: methylchloroisothiazolinone and methylisothiazolinone (entry 39).8

Benzoate is the entry listed most often in shampoo, shower gel, wipes and mouthwash, and phenoxyethanol in cream or lotion, make-up and sun care.

Bar chart of the share of products of each type that list at least one preservative entry: Wipes 87 percent; Shower gel and bath 86 percent; Shampoo 84 percent; Mouthwash 81 percent; Hair colour 81 percent; Conditioner and hair care 79 percent; Cream or lotion 63 percent; Sun care 53 percent; Make-up 52 percent; Soap 38 percent; Toothpaste 29 percent; Deodorant 24 percent; Perfume 15 percent.

Figure 6. Data: Open Beauty Facts.8

The share is lowest for perfume, deodorant, toothpaste and soap. Part 2 explains which products are a low microbiological risk and may need no challenge test.

Two bar charts. Left: products by the number of preservative entries they list: none 10,723; one 6,789; two 4,401; three 1,601; four 314; five or more 94. Right: the pairs of entries listed together most often, led by benzoate with sorbate in 2,892 products.

Figure 7. Data: Open Beauty Facts.8

Of the 13,199 products that list at least one of these entries, 51% list one, 33% list two and 15% list three or more.

6. Ingredients that protect a product without being in the list

A 2022 review describes cosmetic ingredients with antimicrobial properties that can reduce or replace preservatives. It states that two of them, ethylhexylglycerin and caprylyl glycol, are not classified as preservatives in Annex V.10

Bar chart of the number of products in Open Beauty Facts that list each of eight ingredients that also act against micro-organisms: Ethylhexylglycerin 2,488; Caprylyl glycol 2,453; Pentylene glycol 863; 1,2-Hexanediol 747; Hydroxyacetophenone 585; p-Anisic acid or sodium anisate 265; Caprylhydroxamic acid 196; Decylene glycol 117. For comparison, benzoic acid or sodium benzoate are listed in 7,247 products and phenoxyethanol in 5,725.

Figure 8. The eight ingredients are those that a 2024 study names as multifunctional ingredients with antimicrobial properties.11 We left out three that the study also names, butylene glycol, propylene glycol and aminomethyl propanol, because they are used mainly as solvents or to adjust the pH.8

22% of the products in Open Beauty Facts with an ingredient list contain at least one of these eight ingredients. Ethylhexylglycerin and caprylyl glycol are each listed in about 2,500 products, more than any entry of the list except benzoate, phenoxyethanol, benzyl alcohol and sorbate (Figure 4).

74% of the products with one of the eight also list one of the 46 entries without other uses, so the two are often used together. Of the products that list none of these 46 entries, 13% contain one of the eight and 12% contain alcohol. Part 7 explains when such a product may be labelled ‘free from preservatives’.

CosIng, the EU database of cosmetic ingredients, is not legally binding. The Commission states that an ingredient listed in CosIng is not thereby approved for use, and that only the regulation and its annexes decide whether a substance may be used.12

7. Where the EU and GB lists differ

The table shows the five entries that differ between the two lists.1

Entry EU and Northern Ireland Great Britain
Ammonium silver zinc aluminium silicate (silver zinc zeolite) (61) Allowed in spray deodorant and powder foundation, up to 1%. The silver content of the ingredient must not exceed 2.5%.13 Not in the list, so it may not be used as a preservative.
o-Phenylphenol (7) The entry also covers sodium o-phenylphenate. The maximums are 0.2% in rinse-off and 0.15% in leave-on products (as phenol), for the two substances together. Neither may be used in products that may expose the lungs by inhalation, or in oral products.14 o-Phenylphenol only, at the same maximums, with no condition on inhalation or oral products.
Triclosan (25) Toothpaste, hand soap, body soap and shower gel, non-spray deodorant, face powder and blemish concealer, and nail-cleaning products used before artificial nails, up to 0.3%. Not in toothpaste for children under 3, with a label warning.15 The same products at 0.3%, and mouthwash at 0.2%. No condition for children.
Triclocarban (23) All products except mouthwash, up to 0.2%. Not in toothpaste for children under 6, with a label warning. Two impurities: 1 ppm or less each.15 Up to 0.2% in any product, with no condition for children. Two impurities: below 1 ppm each.
Sodium hydroxymethylglycinate (51) Not to be used unless it can be shown that the formaldehyde releasable from all sources is below 0.1%.16 Not to be used if that formaldehyde is 0.1% or more. The limit is the same; the wording differs.17

A product sold in both markets must meet the entry of each market.

Both markets now require the warning ‘releases formaldehyde’ when the total formaldehyde released exceeds 0.001% (10 ppm, parts per million).18,19 In GB, it replaced the warning ‘contains formaldehyde’ above 0.05%. Figure 9 shows when each change applied.

Timeline of changes to the preservative list from 2022 to 2027 in the EU and Northern Ireland and in Great Britain: the deletion of zinc pyrithione (EU 1 March 2022, GB 15 October 2022), the conditions for entry 51, the new warning ‘releases formaldehyde’ above 0.001% (EU 31 July 2022, GB 15 July 2026), the restrictions on triclosan and triclocarban (EU 24 April 2024), the new entry 7 (EU 1 May 2026) and entry 61 (EU 18 May 2026), and the last dates for products made to the old text.

Figure 9. Sources: the amending acts of each market.2,13–19

The regulation that added silver zinc zeolite states why industry asked for it: the number of available preservatives is falling.13 Part 5 gives the history of all changes since 2021.

8. Preservatives that depend on pH

In the water phase of a product, each acid preservative (section 4) is partly in its acid form and partly in the form of its anion. The higher the pH of the product, the smaller the share in the acid form. The share also depends on the pKa of the acid, which is the pH at which half of the acid is in the acid form.

Line chart of the share of six acid preservatives in the acid form between pH 2.5 and pH 7, calculated from their pKa values: Salicylic acid pKa 2.97; Formic acid pKa 3.74; Benzoic acid pKa 4.2; Sorbic acid pKa 4.76; Propionic acid pKa 4.87; Dehydroacetic acid pKa 5.26. Benzoic acid is 33 percent in the acid form at pH 4.5 and 0.5 percent at pH 6.5.

Figure 10. The open circles mark the worked case in this section.20–22

Acid (entry) pKa pH 4 pH 5 pH 6 pH 7
Salicylic acid (3) 2.9720 8.5% 0.92% 0.09% 0.01%
Formic acid (14) 3.7420 35% 5.2% 0.55% 0.05%
Benzoic acid (1) 4.2020 61% 14% 1.6% 0.16%
Sorbic acid (4) 4.7621 85% 37% 5.4% 0.57%
Propionic acid (2) 4.8720 88% 43% 6.9% 0.74%
Dehydroacetic acid (13) 5.2622 95% 65% 15% 1.8%

Share in the acid form at each pH, calculated from the pKa at 25 °C. A table published in 1973 gives the same values within rounding.23 Undecylenic acid (entry 18) is not included, because we found no measured pKa for it.

The acid form is the more active. In tests on six bacteria and yeasts, the acid form of sorbic acid inhibited growth 10 to 600 times more strongly than the anion.24 Above pH 6, where most of the acid is in the anion form, the anion caused more than half of the inhibition for most of the organisms. A later study found that both forms act for benzoic and propionic acids too.25

Worked case: the same sodium benzoate at two pH values

A leave-on cream contains sodium benzoate at the maximum, 0.5% as benzoic acid.

  • At pH 4.5, 33% of it is in the acid form: 0.17% benzoic acid.
  • At pH 6.5, 0.5% of it is in the acid form: 0.0025% benzoic acid, 67 times less.

Share in the acid form = 1 / (1 + 10(pH − pKa)), with pKa 4.20.

9. Why a product fails the challenge test

The challenge test adds known micro-organisms to the product and counts the survivors over 28 days (Part 1). A product can fail the test even with an allowed preservative at its maximum, because in a cream the activity of a preservative depends on how much of it is in the water phase.26 The studies below show how a preservative is lost from the water phase.

The oil phase

Many preservatives dissolve in oil as well as in water. The oil:water partition coefficient, K, is the concentration in the oil divided by the concentration in the water.

Grouped bar chart of the share of four preservatives in the water phase of a cream with 30 percent oil, with a mineral oil and with a vegetable oil: Methylparaben (12): 99 percent with liquid paraffin, 23.7 percent with soya oil; Propylparaben (12a): 82 percent with liquid paraffin, 2.8 percent with soya oil; Butylparaben (12a): 44 percent with liquid paraffin, 0.8 percent with soya oil; Chlorocresol (24): 60 percent with liquid paraffin, 2.0 percent with arachis oil.

Figure 11. Share in the water phase = 1 / (K × φ + 1), where φ is the oil:water ratio, here 30/70.26,27

Line chart of the share of chlorocresol in the water phase of a cream against its oil content, calculated from partition coefficients of 1.53 for liquid paraffin and 116.7 for arachis oil. At 30 percent oil, 60 percent of the chlorocresol is in the water with liquid paraffin and 2 percent with arachis oil.

Figure 12. Partition coefficients from a 1965 study, measured between each oil and water.26

The 1965 study concluded that creams made with a vegetable oil are harder to preserve than creams made with a mineral oil.26 With soya oil, less than 3% of the propylparaben and of the butylparaben stays in the water phase of a cream with 30% oil, because K rises with the length of the ester chain and is far higher for soya oil than for liquid paraffin.27

Surfactants

Non-ionic emulsifiers form micelles, small clusters of emulsifier molecules that take up preservatives. With 5% non-ionic emulsifier, as much as 75% of the methylparaben in an emulsion can be held in the micelles, which leaves 25% for the oil and the water. Below about 1%, the emulsifiers did not interfere significantly.23

Grouped bar chart of methylparaben free in the water of liquid paraffin creams containing 0.1 percent methylparaben in total, at 10 to 50 percent oil. Without emulsifier: 0.11, 0.12, 0.14, 0.16 and 0.20 percent. With 5 percent polysorbate 80: 0.025, 0.027, 0.032, 0.037 and 0.044 percent.

Figure 13. Source: a 1972 study.27

Worked case: methylparaben in a cream with 5% polysorbate 80

  • The 1972 study set a target of 0.2% free methylparaben in the water phase.
  • With 5% polysorbate 80, the cream needed about 0.8% methylparaben in total at 10% oil and about 0.5% at 50% oil. The study reports that these amounts gave an activity close to that of 0.2% methylparaben in water.27
  • The maximum for methylparaben on its own is 0.4% as the acid, which is 0.44% methylparaben (152.15 ÷ 138.12 × 0.4%).1

With the study’s values, methylparaben alone cannot reach the target in these creams without exceeding its maximum.

Other ingredients

Proteins inactivate most preservatives, including quaternary ammonium compounds, phenols, mercury compounds and parabens.23 In submicron emulsions made with lecithin, less than 3% of the benzalkonium chloride (entry 54) was free in the water phase.28

The pack

Range chart of preservative lost to plastic packs in two studies: propylparaben 40 to 50 percent and methylparaben 9 to 16 percent in low-density polyethylene packs at 40 degrees; below 5 percent in polypropylene packs; phenoxyethanol 7 to 8 percent into polyoxymethylene in one month.

Figure 14. Sources: one pharmaceutical study and one cosmetics study.29,30

Plastics can take up preservatives from a product, and the amount depends on the plastic.29,30

Breakdown over time

Bar chart of the half-life of methylchloroisothiazolinone in alkaline solutions: 47 days at pH 8.5, 23 days at pH 9.0, 3.3 days at pH 9.6 and 2 days at pH 10. It was stable in acid solutions.

Figure 15. Methylchloroisothiazolinone is the chlorinated part of entry 39.31

Some preservatives break down in the product. Methylchloroisothiazolinone was stable in acid solutions and broke down faster as the pH rose from 8.5 to 10.31 Bronopol (entry 21) breaks down slowly in acid solutions and faster as the pH and the temperature rise; its breakdown products include formaldehyde and nitrite.32

Most of these studies used simple mixtures or pharmaceutical products. A 1973 review concluded that a preservative must be tested in the cosmetic itself, because other ingredients change its activity.23 The challenge test on the finished product, in its pack, shows whether enough preservative remains active.

10. What to send for the safety report

For a safety report (COS-05), please send the documents listed in Part 4 of this series. For the preservatives, please also send:

  • the INCI name (International Nomenclature of Cosmetic Ingredients), the supplier and the trade name of each preservative or preservative blend, and its percentage in the formula;
  • any preservative that comes with another raw material, as shown in the supplier’s specification;
  • the pH of the finished product;
  • what the product is and where it is applied, for example rinse-off or leave-on, near the eyes, on the lips, in the mouth, as a spray, or for children under three;
  • the pack: its material and type, such as a jar, a pump or a tube;
  • where you sell: Great Britain, Northern Ireland or the EU;
  • the challenge test report, if you have one.

Safety reports and testing from NorrChemica

Our safety report covers the EU and Great Britain: each preservative is checked against the list of each market where you sell.

Cosmetics testing What the safety report includes

Sources

  1. Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products: Articles 2 and 14, and Annex V. EU version consolidated on 18 May 2026: eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2009/1223; GB version: legislation.gov.uk/eur/2009/1223/annex/V
  2. EUR-Lex, Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009: list of acts that modify it, read 19 November 2026. eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:32009R1223
  3. China’s Safety and Technical Standards for Cosmetics now in full effect. CosmeticsDesign, December 2016 (51 permitted preservatives). cosmeticsdesign.com
  4. ChemLinked, China’s Safety and Technical Standards for Cosmetics (STSC), page updated 28 July 2026: ethyl lauroyl arginate HCl added by NMPA Announcement No. 141 of 2020. cosmetic.chemlinked.com
  5. Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, Standards for Cosmetics (MHW Notification No. 331 of 2000), Appendix 3, provisional English translation. mhlw.go.jp/content/001257665.pdf
  6. ASEAN Cosmetic Directive, Annex VI: List of preservatives allowed for use in cosmetic products, version 2026-1, 22 June 2026. asean.org
  7. US Food and Drug Administration, Prohibited & Restricted Ingredients in Cosmetics. fda.gov/cosmetics/laws-regulations/prohibited-restricted-ingredients
  8. Open Beauty Facts, products export of 19 November 2026. Contains information from Open Beauty Facts, made available under the Open Database License (ODbL). world.openbeautyfacts.org
  9. Scientific Advisory Group on Chemical Safety of Non-Food and Non-Medicinal Consumer Products (SAG-CS), Opinion 16: Formaldehyde releasing substances, July 2022, with an addendum dated June 2024. assets.publishing.service.gov.uk
  10. Review article: Preservation of personal care and cosmetic products: effectiveness and safety during the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Cosmetic Science 2022;73(2). library.scconline.org
  11. Deciphering trends in replacing preservatives in cosmetics intended for infants and sensitive population. Scientific Reports 2024;14:19053. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11330455
  12. European Commission, CosIng, the cosmetic ingredient database: legal status of the database. single-market-economy.ec.europa.eu/sectors/cosmetics/cosmetic-ingredient-database_en
  13. Commission Regulation (EU) 2026/909 of 27 April 2026 (entry 61, silver zinc zeolite). eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2026/909/oj
  14. Commission Regulation (EU) 2026/78 of 12 January 2026 (entry 7, o-phenylphenol), applying from 1 May 2026. eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2026/78/oj
  15. Commission Regulation (EU) 2024/996 of 3 April 2024 (entries 23 and 25, triclocarban and triclosan). eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/996/oj
  16. Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/1902 of 29 October 2021 (entry 8 deleted) and Commission Regulation (EU) 2022/1531 of 15 September 2022 (entry 51). eur-lex.europa.eu
  17. The Toys and Cosmetic Products (Restriction of Chemical Substances) Regulations 2022, S.I. 2022/659, regulations 3(7), 3(8) and 4(3). legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2022/659
  18. Commission Regulation (EU) 2022/1181 of 8 July 2022 (warning ‘releases formaldehyde’). eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2022/1181/oj
  19. The Cosmetic Products Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 (Restriction of Chemical Substances) (Amendment and Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2026, S.I. 2026/23, regulations 1, 2(4) and 3. legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2026/23
  20. IUPAC Digitized pKa Dataset, version 2.4a, 2026: values for benzoic, formic, propionic and salicylic acids assessed as reliable. Reproduced by permission of International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (CC BY-NC 4.0). doi:10.5281/zenodo.7236452
  21. Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, ‘Sorbic acid’, as quoted in the Hazardous Substances Data Bank: pKa 4.76 at 25 °C. pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/643460
  22. J. Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 2, 1983, 471–473: pKa of dehydroacetic acid in water, 5.26, as cited in Australian Industrial Chemicals Introduction Scheme, Dehydroacetic acid preservatives: Environment tier II assessment, 28 June 2019. industrialchemicals.gov.au
  23. Modern concepts of cosmetic preservation. Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists 1973;24:663–675. library.scconline.org
  24. The antimicrobial effect of dissociated and undissociated sorbic acid at different pH levels. Journal of Applied Bacteriology 1983;54(3):383–389. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2672.1983.tb02632.x
  25. Inhibition of microbial growth at different pH levels by benzoic and propionic acids and esters of p-hydroxybenzoic acid. International Journal of Food Microbiology 1985. doi:10.1016/0168-1605(85)90035-2
  26. The activity of antibacterials in two-phase systems. Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists 1965;16:15–30. library.scconline.org
  27. Preservatives for pharmaceuticals. Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists 1972;23:703–720. library.scconline.org
  28. Distribution of benzalkonium chloride into the aqueous phases of submicron dispersed systems: emulsions, aqueous lecithin dispersion and nanospheres. AAPS PharmSciTech 2020;21(1):7. doi:10.1208/s12249-019-1540-7
  29. Sorption of antimicrobial agents in blow-fill-seal packs. Pharmaceutical Development and Technology 2012;17(1):84–93. doi:10.3109/10837450.2010.516438
  30. A study on the interaction with preservatives and UV-filters, packaging materials for sunscreen preservation. Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Scientists of Korea 2010;36(4):259–263.
  31. The effects of pH on the degradation of isothiazolone biocides. Tribology International 1992;25(4):281–287. doi:10.1016/0301-679X(92)90065-U
  32. The activity and safety of the antimicrobial agent Bronopol (2-bromo-2-nitropropan-1,3-diol). Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists 1978;29:3–24. library.scconline.org

About this article. We read the sources on 19 November 2026. The two lists come from the EU consolidated text of 18 May 2026 on EUR-Lex, checked against EUR-Lex’s list of later amending acts, and from the GB text on legislation.gov.uk, checked against the statutory instruments that amended it. The pKa values come from the IUPAC dataset and from the other sources named in the table. The counts of names and CAS numbers in the list, the maximums as the salt, the shares in the acid form and in the water phase, and the worked cases are our calculations. We read the 1965, 1972, 1973 and 1978 papers on the scanned journal pages, and the other studies from their abstracts. The numbers for Japan and ASEAN come from their official lists, and those for China from trade publications. This article is not legal advice.

© 2026 NorrChemica. All rights reserved.
Content may not be reproduced without written permission.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.